I
From this I am guessing you are not from or were not raised in a rural area? Your assumptions about lack of schooling opportunities and work almost come across classist. Bonded students are not being sent to the most rural and remote areas in Australia. Some areas, such as Port Macquarie, Wagga and Albury have the highest qualities of life. These aren’t towns with 500 people, these are regional areas that are thriving communities with a myriad of specialty departments. I for one am so incredibly grateful to have been raised in regional Australia, mentalities like these are hurtful to rural communities and for doctors who can and will have flourishing careers in these areas.If training in rural areas really made people better doctors and more attractive candidates for specialty training positions, then we wouldn't have these workforce distribution issues.
Living and working is hard in rural areas, there is no way around this. Suicide rates are high, drug addictions are high, there are antisocial elements from being so disconnected, they're hard to get around, lack of schooling opportunities for children, lack of work opportunities outside of primary industries, the list goes on... and for this, junior doctors who are often start postgraduate training around the time they settle down with a partner, or have some kids, it is very hard to justify to live in these rural areas.
For young junior doctors, its hard to move to a rural area with a spouse and kid for intern or residency year, just to throw it all up again to move to somewhere you can actually train as a registrar. Take a look at this quote from an article published in the AMA about the factors that lead to doctors deciding where to practice
This is the entire idea behind the rural training pipeline the government is funding. To allocate extended terms during a registrar to essentially spend a large amount of their time, training in a regional training hub... same with opening medical schools in Orange, Rockhampton, Shepparton, Wagga, Bendigo, Midlura, Dubbo, etc...
Knowing about the limitations of a BMP is not self serving, or self interest. It's reality. It's the reason that 95%+ of people break the bond for a financial cost, because despite earning more in a rural area, or getting more work, or more 'hands on experience', it is a harder lifestyle that can hurt your future.
villanelle35 - I wouldn't be too worried, personally I would take the 5 year one. A bonded agreement is not the end of the world, mostly due to its ability to be broken and payed off (lets be realistic here: is the primary motivator behind the scheme for the government), and you will 100% change with what speciality you want to be before you graduate
