I'm not sure any of our regulars are or have been at Salmond, so I don't know if we can provide you with an informed opinion... (And uninformed opinion is generally based on rumours and tend to be particularly negative about everything other than, say Carrington.)
I must say this is getting blown out of proportion (because it honestly doesn't matter as much as it's made to sound like), and I'll quote you the best piece of advice from that thread you linked to:
I must say this is getting blown out of proportion (because it honestly doesn't matter as much as it's made to sound like), and I'll quote you the best piece of advice from that thread you linked to:
Accept it. At the end of the day you will have fun in any hall, including Salmond. Flatting gets old fast, you will have plenty other years to go flatting.
So go to a hall, meet people and have fun.
Sorry about having weird panic attacks about next year on the forum. I have definitely decided to accept their application.